
L to R: Ben Lauer, Bri Houtman, Robert Pike, Natalie Cutcher, and Travis Xavier Brown. Photo by DJ Corey Photography.
“’Romeo & Juliet’ is a comedy except when it isn’t.” These words, a quote from Faction of Fools founding artistic director Dr. Matthew R. Wilson, refer to one of the more tedious assertions in Shakespeare scholarship: that Romeo & Juliet is structurally a comedy. Unlike many of those essays, a Faction of Fools’ delightful revival of the Bard’s romance truly embraces the hysterics written into the text. Add to this, Commedia dell’ Arte’s sensibilities of heightened archetypes and physical goofiness, and you have a recipe for a truly gut-busting hour of theatrical joy.
…a truly gut-busting hour of theatrical joy…superb direction of Kathryn Zoerb…an absolute success.
This production’s first and best move is its joyful approach to multi-casting. (As a note for readers, this production utilizes a rotating cast, labeled as the Capulet cast and Montague cast. I saw the Capulet cast and will only refer to those actors.) Each of the five cast members plays at least a pair of characters, using archetypal masks and physical transformation to distinguish between them. This separation gives the cast full license to be as ridiculous with the text as they choose and do they ever choose it. As Mercutio (Robert Pike) becomes Bluto from “Animal House” and The Friar (Natalie Cutcher) transforms into a flabbergasted straight man, the story’s sillier elements rise in prominence to meet them. Swapping roles quickly allows for extra humor such as when Ben Lauer rapidly changes between Paris and the Nurse to melodramatically mourn a fallen Juliet (Bri Houtman), a scene that left me cackling. The performers inject humor like this into just about every scene of the production. So much of that success is owed to the superb direction of Kathryn Zoerb. Her scenes are impeccably readable, the performers have a near-flawless grasp of verse, and her additions to the text are carefully considered and universally hysterical. Though she may be iterating on a previous production, her work stands fully on its own.
I am perhaps most impressed by how economic the design is in its comedic focus. Johnny Weissgerber’s set, eloquently described as a Pandora’s Box, not only transforms a set of cubes into every meaningful location in the show (including a spectacularly funny turn as a Crucifix), it serves as a delightful source of physical comedy. I giggled each time Romeo (Travis Xavier Brown) would enter the stage skating on one knee on the wheeled bottom of the set. Those moments were heightened by Jesse Terrill’s delightfully goofy score that summons the atmosphere of a Buster Keaton-esque silent movie. Of course, Tara Cariaso’s spectacular masks remain a sight to behold. Every detail—from the easily, but not too easily, changed costumes to the painted background with a “wet paint” sign slapped clear in the middle—heightens everything around it so the audience is constantly searching for a chance to laugh.
The core comedic conceit of the production does mean that the show sometimes feels like it’s fighting with the text. While the turn to comedy is easily adapted in the rosy first half, when our characters struggle, the show has to work harder and add more to keep that rate of humor afloat. While that work mostly pays off, it undercuts the genuine attempts at drama the actors make, save one truly chill-inducing moment of pathos—the death of Mercutio. That scene had time to sit and let the remaining cast react to the moment’s darkness rather than simply moving on to the next scene for a new gag. The other dramatic moments would have benefitted from a similar procedure.
Despite this, I can only call this silly take on tragedy an absolute success. The cast and creative team have deftly adapted one of Shakespeare’s most well-trod scripts into something that not only fits their oeuvre but feels genuinely fresh. Throughout the hour, I fully devolved into a fit of awkward hysterics more times than I’d care to admit, and even with the shaky dramatics, I left fully affected by the classic tale. More than anything, this highlights the essential value of maintaining and iterating on classical forms and text. Hundreds of years past their date, they can still be used to innovate.
Running Time: One hour and 10 minutes with no intermission.
Advisory: Family friendly with some adult humor and themes; recommended for 12 and up.
“A Commedia Romeo & Juliet” runs through February 3, 2024, Friday-Sunday at Capitol Hill Art Workshop, 545 7th St. SE, Washington, D.C. 20003. Performances begin promptly at their scheduled time. Open captioned performances on Friday, 1/26 at 7:30 pm; Saturday, 1/27 at 2 pm and 7:30 pm. Medical Mask required performances on Sat 1/27 at 2 pm and Sat 2/3 at 2 pm. For more information and tickets, please call 202-547-6839 or go online.












