
(From left to right) Firdous Bamji, Ethan J. Miller, and Dani Stoller. Photo by Ryan Maxwell Photography.
Jonathan Spector’s “This Much I Know” is currently having its East Coast premiere at Theater J. It was the winner of the 2023 Theatre Bay Area Will Glickman Award for best new play premiere. A time-bending, narrative arc-diverting, and deeply intellectual commentary on history, relationships, and all the things that we think we know, the play, in many ways, puts the utter fragility of the human mind front and center. The characters orbit a theatrical space of memories recalled and also those memories that have been lost, whether altered by time or somehow replaced by “other” versions.
A time-bending, narrative arc-diverting, and deeply intellectual commentary on history, relationships, and all the things that we think we know…Hayley Finn, Theater J’s Artistic Director, sits in the director’s chair…She quite masterfully succeeds.
The play opens with psychology professor Lukesh lecturing to the audience. He compels us to question how our mind makes connections, what our eyes actually see or don’t see, and why any of this matters to the story at hand. While the quasi-confessional lectures help reveal more of Lukesh’s personality and thus provide a basis for his impending crisis of conscience, the lectures also speak to the bigger picture: that of the different modes of thought that are available to the human mind. Inspired by Daniel Kahneman’s Thinking Fast and Slow, Spector dives deep into what triggers memory and the question of how sure we are about the “rightness” of our responses.
Lukesh’s wife, Natalya, has been involved in a car accident. While she emerged unscathed, the biker who pulled out in front of her was not so lucky. This trauma and the associated triggers indirectly lead Natalya on a trek through Russia with nothing but a text to her husband by way of goodbye—a humorous visual moment that adds some lightness to loss. This seems to be a recurrent motif in the play. Through loss and devastation, there is usually some lighthearted moment to be mined. Natalya’s grandmother was apparently very close friends with Joseph Stalin’s daughter, Svetlana, another character who gets plenty of stage time. There is a carefully orchestrated interweaving of stories, eras, and cultural atmospheres. On the surface, they are distinctly different but, at their core, may share some uncomfortable similarities, as evinced, for example, by Harold, a student of Lukesh’s with white nationalist origins. The visual of Stalin’s talking portrait as interchangeable with that of Harold’s White, supremacist father is indeed a strikingly provocative one.
The cast of three slide so easily from one character to the next. As the vulnerable, albeit self-absorbed Natalya and also Svetlana, the at-times confused “daddy’s girl,” Dani Stoller brings a defiant malleability that works beautifully. Firdous Bamji’s Lukesh is a strong lead and a wonderfully surprising character actor as he morphs into a few other roles to include one of Svetlana’s “besties.” Ethan J. Miller who plays Harold, as well as a series of quirky Russian characters, proves himself an accent acrobat, veritably flipping from one voice and character into the next. Hayley Finn, Theater J’s Artistic Director, sits in the director’s chair for this one. Her task is a difficult one; she must put together a puzzle and yet, not make it seem like a puzzle at all. She quite masterfully succeeds. There is a seamlessness here that makes it all just work.
Misha Kachman’s scenic design, in conjunction with Colin K. Bills’ lighting, is a revelation. Harkening a game board and featuring a series of slidable panels and floor sections, the set serves to ground the chaos of memories, imagined moments, and the reality we sometimes refuse to see. Projections (Mona Kasra) and sound design (Sarah O’Halloran) take production values to another level—impressive is an understatement. When all was said and done, I came away from this one with new ideas about how thoughts get compartmentalized and how hard-won, and yet easily dismissed, our confidence can be when it comes to knowing what we know.
Running Time: Two hours and 30 minutes including one 15-minute intermission.
“This Much I Know” runs through February 25, 2024 at Theater J, 1529 16th St NW, Washington, DC 20036. For more information and to purchase tickets, call the Box Office at (202) 777-3210 from 1:00 –5:00 pm, Monday–Friday, and one hour prior to performances, or go online.Masks are required for Thursday evening and Saturday matinee performances.













