
Benhamou family and Molly – Danielle Skraastad (Marcelle), Ariel Eliaz (Charles), Ethan J. Miller (Daniel), Dani Stoller (Elodie), and Jourdan Lewanda (Molly). Photo by Ryan Maxwell Photography.
Joshua Harmon’s 2024 Tony-nominated, epically expansive script, “Prayer for the French Republic,” investigates the horrors of the Holocaust, albeit as more of a side note than headline, holding the atrocities up as a sort of generational mirror to events transpiring in modern-day France. This is right after Trump has just been elected the first time, when hatred and attacks against Jewish people are on the rise, and following something of an exodus of Jews out of Paris.
…Hayley Finn…injects energy into each segment…The cast is…spectacular.
The Benhamou and Salomon families are at a crossroads. Marcelle Benhamou (Danielle Skraastad), a psychiatrist who fuels the adage ‘physician heal thyself,’ is worried about the fate of her family, and the well-being of her son, Daniel (Ethan J. Miller), who persists in wearing a kippah, announcing to the world his religious affiliation. It’s better if they just don’t know, concludes Marcelle, to much gasping and semi-veiled shock. Yet, despite the increase in violence against Jewish people in this once-safe enclave, she is not ready to abandon her home. On the other hand, her husband, Charles (Ariel Eliaz), has had enough and is consequently determined to set down roots in Israel. This will-they-or-won’t-they struggle consumes the bulk of the three-act play at Theater J as the stakes of uprooting your entire lives as a direct reaction to being bullied go so much deeper than what this family experiences. There are centuries of hatred, violence, and retreat playing out in the span of three hours.
To accentuate his point, Harmon also tells the story of Pierre Salomon (Jeremy Allen Crawford), Marcelle’s father, his father, and his grandparents. This is a generational play that covers the post-WWII period to 2016, and yet the terms of each of the narrative arcs don’t necessarily hinge on one another as is often times the case with plays of this nature. The saga of Irma (Brigid Cleary) and Adolphe (Stephen Patrick Martin), Pierre’s grandparents, centers rather quietly on the worry and fear of the unknown, of what might be lurking outside their Parisian apartment door. Theirs is an obliviousness that refuses to confront itself. Lucien, Pierre’s father, grieves the rest of his family while maintaining a brave façade for a son who needs to grow up not believing that what he’s seen. The horrors to which he’s been exposed are the sum total of what life is all about.
Back in present-day Paris, the question of what it means to be Jewish and what responsibilities lay therein becomes the impassable “let’s not” between Marcelle and her brother ,Patrick (a fantastically fun to watch Cody Nickell). Patrick blames Marcelle’s husband for influencing his sister’s move toward orthodox traditions. Marcelle blames Patrick for taking her for granted. Neither wants Marcelle and her family to move to Israel, but do they have a choice? This seems to constitute the crux of Harmon’s play: are choices truly choices at all?
Theater J’s artistic director, Hayley Finn, helms this production. Her appreciation of the smaller details of family life and the way in which she spotlights the frailty of the human condition during even more mundane moments helps rein Harmon’s lengthy piece in and injects energy into each segment. The cast is, as is generally the case with Theater J productions, spectacular. As Marcelle, Danielle Skraastad is the beating heart of the Benhamou/Salomon family—and the show. Her vacillation between unraveling and keeping it together for the sake of those she loves is absolutely fascinating to behold. Ethan J. Miller transfixes as both Daniel and the character’s great grandfather, Lucien. Jourdan Lewanda as cousin Molly is the perfect balance of playful and meek, while Dani Stoller as Elodie does a soap box like no one I have seen—pure passion mixed with the driest of sarcasm combine to mesmerizing effect.
Misha Kachman’s naturalistic set design gives plenty on which to focus as the windows into the Benhamou’s/Salomon’s lives are thrown wide open. Combined with Colin K. Bills’ lighting and Sarah O’ Halloran’s sound design, the overall stage ambiance perfectly keeps with the themes of family strife, generational nostalgia, and historic suffering. Clocking in at just over three hours, “Prayer for the French Republic” is admittedly a bit of a commitment but one you will be glad you made.
Running time: Three hours with two intermissions.
“Prayer for the French Republic” runs through November 24, 2024 at Theatre J, 1529 16th St NW, Washington, DC 20036. For more information andr to purchase tickets, please go online.













