
Ryan Alexander as Jimmy Ray and Emma Markey as Alice. Photo by Patrick Ryan.
Many people think of Steve Martin as a comedian—as goofy gumshoe Rigby Reardon in “Dead Men Don’t Wear Plaid” or as con-man Freddy Benson in “Dirty Rotten Scoundrels.” In “Bright Star,” we see a different side of the performer. Here, Stephen Martin (as he is billed in Catholic University of America’s recent production) has joined forces with fellow bluegrass enthusiast, Eddie Brickell, to pen a shining musical.
…a stellar performance of this bluegrass-based production…
The student actors outdid themselves in a stellar performance of this bluegrass-based production. The show swings back and forth between two time periods in early 20th century North Carolina. In 1923, we meet Alice Murphy and Jimmy Ray, teenage lovers hailing from different social spheres. This idyllic romance is threatened when we learn that Alice is expecting a child. Then there is 1945, where we meet Alice again, now college-educated and a sharp-tongued literary editor. Yet, what has happened to Jimmy Ray? Will the romance be rekindled? We also meet Billy, a young writer just returned home from military service during World War II and who now hopes to be published in Alice’s magazine.
The show was anchored by a tremendous performance by Emma Markey as Alice. Her forceful opening song, “If You Knew My Story,” introduces the two time frames of the tale. Madonnina Gullo also shone as Lucy, Alice’s assistant during the 1945 timeline, especially in the number “Another Round,” sung and played in the Western Swing style popular in the 1940s. Ryan Alexander was excellent as Jimmy Ray, especially in the heartbreaking solo, “Heartbreaker,” in which he laments that he must be ever distant from Alice because of a terrible action by his father, the powerful Mayor (played wonderfully by Cayden Wallace). Chase Nester performed strong as Billy in all respects, but especially in a scene in which he lays a rose at his mother’s grave (“She’s Gone,” a wonderful duet with Jackson Biggs as Daddy Cane).
Allison Howlett as Billy’s love interest Margo, Joey Depto as Alice’s second assistant Daryl, Racheal Brandon as Mama Murphy, and Robert Garza as Daddy Murphy rounded out the excellent main cast, though others contributed as well. For example, Audrey Clement and Mulunesh Creaghan each added to the bluegrass sound as fiddlers, both as show musicians and also on stage as musical performers in a square-dancing scene.
The set of scenic designer Samina Vieth was minimal but very effective and made for smooth transitions between scenes and locales. Props included pieces suggesting the 1940s, such as a cathedral-style radio and glowing jars appearing to be lit by fireflies. The costumes of Cody Von Ruden were similarly true to the 1920s and 1940s eras in which they were set. Dialect coach Tonya Beckman was highly successful in creating accents consistent with the North Carolina setting.
The production was directed under the sure hand of Jay D. Brock, who told Maryland Theatre Guide: “I was very excited to be able to work on this musical, as it is a piece that I have really loved for many years. I love the themes of redemption, forgiveness, and the reunification of family. It is also reminiscent of a Shakespearean tragicomedy (which are my favorite plays in his canon) where you have the comedy of one plot juxtaposed to the tragedy of another plot….” The show also recalled aspects of Frank Wedekind’s “Spring Awakening,” though events here turn out far happier. The show also contains numerous pithy observations about the human condition, such as “Truth walks with us like a shadow until one day it merges with us.” Sadly, “Bright Star” had a too-brief, three-day run.
Running Time: Two hours and 30 minutes, including a 15-minute intermission.
“Bright Star” ran April 25-27, 2025 at the Callan Theater, Catholic University’s Rome School of Music, Drama, and Art, 348 University Drive NE, Washington, DC 20064. For more information on upcoming events, please go online.














