
Andy Shaw as Bud Davenport and Peter Marsh as Doug Simon. Photo by Heather Regan Photography.
“Gutenberg! The Musical,” written and composed by Scott Brown and Anthony King, is a hysterical, self-aware production about two aspiring, musical theater writers, Doug Simon (Peter Marsh) and Bud Davenport (Andy Shaw). The Broadway revival in 2023 featured Josh Gad and Andrew Rannells. The two have created a musical about Johannes Gutenberg, the 15th century German inventor of the printing press, and are trying to find a producer for the show. Performed in the City of Fairfax Theatre Company’s (CFTC) new black box theatre, this is a perfect production to showcase the new theater, and its intimacy allows the audience to feel fully immersed in the musical.
…laughing the entire production…Marsh and Shaw (and Bradley) keep the audience fully engaged.
Doug and Bud immediately inform the audience that the musical is historical fiction, and remind us of this throughout the performance. Fiction should be emphasized. Do not come expecting accurate information about Johannes Gutenberg like one can find in “Hamilton.” Instead, think more “Spamalot” with a cast of two. With that caveat in mind, “Gutenberg! The Musical” is a great show to see, especially if you want to be laughing the entire production. A very fictional retelling is only a part of the show’s humor. Another part comes as Doug and Bud explain to the audience (and hopefully a producer) the different elements each song is trying to accomplish, including defining an opening number or a charm song. The result is a musical surprisingly informative about the structure of a musical.
With the “on-script” discussions to “off-script” insights into the life of the actors (or at least Doug and Bud) and their anxieties about whether the show will find a producer or not, we are entertainingly brought between three different layers of life on stage. Despite the meta-theatre juggling act, the show is remarkably easy to follow, with each layer enriching the comedy.
Since Marsh and Shaw are the only two actors on stage, hats are brilliantly used to distinguish between unseen, additional cast for their musical. Sometimes Marsh and Shaw are wearing as many as six hats at once. They not only manage to keep track of all the characters, but are able to switch between them and showcase their quirks in seconds with impressive ease. Pianist and music director Rachel Bradley is just as much a part of the show as the two actors in silently responding to their antics. She has her own hat marking her as part of the production (similar hats can be found on the Stage Manager and Box Office staff adding another layer of charm to the show). Props are very simple and sparse, but that only adds to the bigger picture of trying to find a producer for “Gutenberg!” Even with limited props and other people to bounce off of each other as is the nature of the show, Marsh and Shaw (and Bradley) keep the audience fully engaged. They makes the shifting between roles look absolutely effortless.
The audience laughed non-stop throughout the entire show. Coupled with the intimate space of the theater, CFTC’s production of “Gutenberg! The Musical” is well-worth seeing.
Running Time: Approximately two hours with one 15-minute intermission.
“Gutenberg! The Musical” runs through September 21, 2025 at the














