
(L-R): Catherine Freytag, Adam Grumet, Lola Zein, Clara Adesnik-Chu, Libby Heaton, and Aarian Arora. Photo by Ben Zastrow.
When life gives you eggs (make an omelette)! Welcome to St. Andrew’s Players’ “Something Rotten!”
This musical comedy opened on Broadway in 2015, with a book by John O’Farrell and Karey Kirkpatrick. Music and lyrics were composed by Karey and Wayne Kirkpatrick. It was nominated for several Tony awards including: Best Musical, Best Original Score, and Best Leading Actor in a Musical, among others.
The story follows brothers Nick and Nigel Bottom as they struggle against the exhaustive success of “The Bard”, the infamous William Shakespeare. With dwindling funds, and a baby on the way, Nick Bottom turns to the nephew of a renowned soothsayer, Nostradamus, to get a jump on what Shakespeare’s next big hit will be. Piecing together spotty prophecies, Nostradamus informs Nick that the next big thing in theatre will be “musicals” where the dialogue stops, and the plot is conveyed through song. Full of pop-culture references, tap numbers, and contemporary gags, the Bottom brothers dive into their adventure composing “Omelette: The Musical.”
Starting off strong, Adam Grumet, as Nick Bottom, exhibited just how much he hated Shakespeare in “God, I Hate Shakespeare.” His fists shaking with barely restrained rage and strong voice brilliantly introduced the main conflict of the show.
Tumbling onstage with a frantic liveliness, Cameron Best as Thomas Nostradamus brought a ceaseless energy with his performance. His clear, yet effortlessly characterized, vocals projected easily across the rows of audience members, making him a standout performer in every scene. The show-stopping number “A Musical” sent audiences roaring as Best flaunted his physicality with humorous hip shakes and a large group dance number.
Perhaps the most entertaining duo to watch on stage, both Best and Grumet shined in their roles while playing off of each other. Their comedic timing, and best-friend chemistry, elevated the scripted gags, as their energies built off one another to send audience members into laughing fits.
The show kicks off with “Welcome to the Renaissance” and Alexandra Boehm, Chelsea Lin, Ilsa Shannon, and Alex Valdivia as the St. Andrew’s Players Costuming Team, certainly delivered on that front. With period-specific costumes, they managed to create a unique individualism for the main characters onstage, while keeping a uniform look throughout the ensemble. The most impressive aspect were the hand-sewn capes made for the Puritans, which elevated their threatening mystique, and had a fun, colorful, surprise when reversed.
Among those Puritans, Catherine Freytag as Portia brought a level of light-hearted innocence that differed from the other characters. Her characteristic head tilts brought the character to life, and her sure, clear voice ensured that every word was absorbed by the audience.
Another standout performer onstage, Matty Beale as Robin, a member of the Bottom’s acting troupe, was always committed to the bit. Their exaggerated reactions, and consistent listen-respond acting style were benefitted by their definitive stage presence, which all contributed to their uproarious performance.
Tackling live instrumentals is always a challenge, and the “Something Rotten!” Show Band certainly delivered. From their quick overture to high-energy songs, they never missed a note or a cue and complemented the engaging atmosphere of the show.
From Puritans to soothsayers, and Shakespeare to eggs, St. Andrew’s production of “Something Rotten!” was a delight, leaving audiences in fits of giggles, and reminding them “to thine own self, be true.”
The performance reviewed was presented Saturday, February 21, 2026 at 2 pm.
Review submitted by Bella Bean of West Springfield High School.














