
The cast of “A Gentleman’s Guide To Love And Murder” at Olney Theatre Center. Photo by Teresa Castracane Photography.
What do you do when you find out you are in succession for an Earldom and there are seven people in line in front of you? If you are Monty Navarro, the answer is to kill off those relatives to earn that Earldom. “A Gentleman’s Guide To Love And Murder” answers this question in its musical adaptation of Roy Horniman’s book Israel Rank: The Autobiography of A Criminal. Written by Steven Lutvak and Robert L. Freedman, “A Gentleman’s Guide To Love And Murder” won four Tony awards in 2014 including Best Musical. Directed by Eleanor Holdridge, the production at Olney Theatre showcases why it is absolutely hysterical and had the audience laughing throughout the whole performance. The production excels at highlighting the physical action and reaction that is the core of the comedy of the musical against the backdrop of an absolutely gorgeous set that brings the show to life.
…a fast-paced show and you keep you laughing the entire time.
Tom Story brilliantly plays all seven members of the D’ysquith Family. It takes skill to effortlessly switch between so many uniquely identifiable characters as easily as he does. Each time Story dies on stage, he has the audience in stitches. It is worth seeing this show just to see this element of the show play out.
Jacob Tischler as Monty Navarro balances this out perfectly with a very serious Monty who truly believes he is justified in his decisions for murder. Tischler earnestly speaks directly to the audience telling his story as the action unfolds around him. Monty is divided between two love interests, Sibella Howard (Sumié Yotsukura) and Phoebe D’Ysquith (Sadie Koopman). A perfect balance once again describes the dynamic between these actresses. Yotsukura brings out a flirtatious and charming Sibella and Koopman balances her with a reflective and pious Phoebe.
The Ensemble deserves their own shout out. Simone Ballinger-Brown, Anna Maria C. Ferrari, Benjamin Lurye, Canter Irene O’May, Decarlo J. Raspberry, and Karen Vincent all add their own comedy chops to the production. A portrait gallery of the cast as D’ysquith family members surrounds the stage. It is a delight when it is brought to life by the ensemble members themselves popping out of their portraits.
Some of the costume changes that Story goes through are impressive, both in speed of costume changes and in managing costumes for each of his D’ysquith family members. Costume Designer Sarah Cubbage plays a huge role in making all of the characters pop. Costume changes can be as simple as hats with more bees on them, running back and forth across the stage, to full changes in such short amount of time into more complex costumes. Each of the cast members having several beautiful changes of clothing (even if they are, as the show jokes, “sick of wearing black”). All of the costumes are stunning.
The passerelle setup (a walkway from the stage that surrounds the orchestra) allows the audience to watch the fantastic, seven-piece orchestra lead by Christopher Youstra. Despite the orchestra being reduced, the balance is not an issue. With the passerelle, the cast gets to interact directly with the orchestra as they move towards the audience. At times, they are sitting right at the edge of the passerelle, interacting with the audience.
Set designer John Coyne built a gorgeous multilayered set. In the very back of the set, a projector screen allows for even more unique touches. These projections by Zavier Augustus Lee Taylor are very well done and do not replace the set entirely as is popular these days. They add visual flavor to a the physical set. Olney Theatre goes all out and this show is no exception.
In terms of individual songs, “Poison in My Pocket” stood out with the stage transformed into a wintery, ice skating scene. The ensemble acting out ice skating throughout the song is a well choreographed and the wintery scene transforms the stage.
Olney Theatre’s production of “A Gentleman’s Guide To Love And Murder” is a fast-paced show and will keep laughing the entire time. It is worth coming to see how Tom Story manages to play so many characters, and the set and costumes are added bonuses that make this a strong and delightful production.
Running Time: Two hours and 30 minutes with one intermission.
Advisory: If this was a film, it would be rated PG13 in a film for violence and sensuality.
“A Gentleman’s Guide To Love And Murder” runs through August 23, 2026 at Roberts Mainstage, Olney Theatre, 2001 Olney-Sandy Spring Road, Olney, MD 20832. For more information and to purchase tickets, call the Box Office at 301-924-2400 or go online.












