
(L to R) Gavin Hubbard, Mylo Cluff (back), Jordan Lohmeyer, Brett Womack, Maura Lacy (back), Stephen Yednock, Michael McGovern (back), Lori Bonnette. Photo by Matt Liptak.
There is something undeniably charming about stepping into a world where handwritten letters, department store romances, and a little holiday magic can bring two people together. “She Loves Me,” the classic musical by Joe Masteroff, Jerry Bock, and Sheldon Harnick, takes audiences to 1930s Budapest, where employees at Maraczek’s Parfumerie spend their days bickering and their nights falling for anonymous pen pals. There have been several adaptations of the 1937 play “Parfumerie” by Hungarian playwright Miklós László, including the 1940 film “The Shop Around the Corner,” 1949’s “The Good Old Summertime,” and “You’ve Got Mail” in 1998. The musical made its Broadway debut in 1963 with revival in 2013. At the Little Theatre of Alexandria, director Mitchell Aiello begins building that world before the story even starts. During the overture, performers move through the aisles and throughout the theatre, blurring the line between stage and audience and making the entire space feel like part of the bustling parfumerie. It is an immersive touch that immediately draws the audience in and sets the tone for a production filled with period charm.
The staging makes imaginative use of the theatre, the design creates a beautiful sense of place, and the cast fills that world with warmth, humor, and heart.
The production’s visual world is one of its greatest strengths. Set designer Julie Fischer creates a gorgeous environment that captures the beauty and detail of a classic 1930s storefront. The period-appropriate props, designed by Brooke Angel Markley and Jennifer Rubio, add to the illusion, while costume designers Farrell Hartigan and Juliana DiFrancesco transport audiences to another time. The women’s colorful dresses contrast beautifully with the men’s more subdued suits, giving each character a distinct visual identity. As the story progresses, the men’s wardrobes begin to take on more color, subtly reflecting the warmth and optimism the women bring into their lives. Lighting designer Ari McSherry further enhances the atmosphere, complementing the set and costumes and bringing this romantic world to life.
The performances are where this production finds its greatest sparks, particularly in Shelby Young’s Amalia Balash and Brandon Schenk’s Steven Kodaly. Young makes a memorable entrance in a bright yellow dress, a literal flash of sunshine that injects an immediate burst of life into the production. Her quick delivery, bright presence, and natural energy make Amalia instantly engaging. In “Vanilla Ice Cream,” Young brings a wonderful mix of comedy and genuine emotion, capturing the character’s romantic excitement while finding the humor in her own flustered reactions. It is a delightful performance that gives Amalia both personality and heart.
As Steven Kodaly, Schenk is a force to be reckoned with. In a cast full of talent, he consistently commands the spotlight with sharp comedic instincts, confident physicality, and an ease of movement that makes even his simplest entrances entertaining. Schenk glides across the stage, making Kodaly’s devious charm impossible to ignore. His chemistry with Maura Lacy’s Ilona Ritter adds another layer of fun, as the two play beautifully off each other’s flirtation and comic timing. Lacy brings a fiery personality to Ilona, with expressive physical comedy and delightfully specific choices that make the character a joy to watch. Just look for the little hip bump she adds after each “Thank you, madam,” a tiny detail that says so much about Ilona’s personality. Their chemistry is on full display in “Ilona,” a playful, sensual, and hilarious number that had the audience eating it up.
Michael McGovern’s Ladislav Sipos is warm and thoughtfully characterized, proving that a character who calls himself an oaf can still be one of the most likable people onstage. Mylo Cluff is a delight as Arpad, the delivery boy whose boyish enthusiasm and eagerness to keep up with the older employees make him feel like a shadow trying to become a real boy. Cluff pairs a lovely vocal performance with physical comedy and an infectious sincerity that make the character’s smaller moments especially funny and endearing. Antony Galace gives Georg Nowack an approachable, slightly awkward charm that fits the character’s big heart and unpolished romantic appeal. Phil Krzywicki also brings a welcome kindness and steadiness to Mr. Maraczek, providing a solid performance that helps ground the story.
The ensemble brings welcome vocal strength and atmosphere to the production, with featured performers Rachael Fine and Stephen Yednock standing out. When the full company comes together, the world of the parfumerie feels alive. “Twelve Days to Christmas” is a particularly enjoyable example of Aiello’s staging making excellent use of the space. The growing activity and festive chaos capture the frantic excitement of the holiday season, filling the stage with movement and energy while keeping the busy shop at the center of it all.
That energy can occasionally become a challenge elsewhere in the production. “She Loves Me” thrives on character-driven comedy, and while several performers find a natural rhythm, some jokes land more softly than expected. At times, there is so much happening onstage that the focus becomes scattered, making it difficult to know where the audience’s attention should go, particularly during the Café Imperiale scene before the end of Act One. A few scene transitions also slow the pacing, interrupting the momentum between musical numbers.
The pit delivers an impressive performance of the score, bringing the music to life with energy and style, even overpowering the actors at times. Despite those moments of imbalance, its musical energy remains a definite asset to the production.
“She Loves Me” is an ensemble show, and its charm comes from the way all the pieces work together. From the performers who bring the parfumerie’s colorful personalities to life to the crew and production team who build a detailed, inviting world around them, there is a clear sense of collective effort on display. The staging makes imaginative use of the theatre, the design creates a beautiful sense of place, and the cast fills that world with warmth, humor, and heart. While some pacing and comedic moments could be sharper, the production offers plenty to enjoy, and its final reveal lands with satisfying timing, giving the romance a lovely finish. The Little Theatre of Alexandria has delivered a production that reminds us just how much magic can be made when an entire company works together.
Running Time: Approximately two hours and 30 minutes, including a 15-minute intermission.
“She Loves Me” runs through November 7, 2026, at the Little Theatre of Alexandria, 600 Wolfe Street, Alexandria, Virginia. Performances are Thursday through Saturday at 8 p.m. and Sunday at 2 p.m. Tickets are $36, plus a service fee. For more information and to purchase tickets, call the Box Office at 703-683-0496 or go online.














