![]()
Socialism and anarchism are the subtle undertones present in The Iceman Cometh – overridden by pipe dreams and attempts to cure them in The Fells Point Corner Theatre’s production of Eugene O’Neill’s American classic The Iceman Cometh. Directed by Lynda McClary the play is filled with characters, though none too memorable, and little anecdotes that allow glimpses into the life of the downtrodden in 1912 America.
The set is a simple saloon, well outfitted with a hodgepodge of mismatched chairs and tables; old yellowing wallpaper and wood paneling on the walls. Designer Kathi Panos creates a simple but realistic space for this play to unfold in; a corner devoted to the bar itself, with bottles lined on the shelves and black and white paintings plastering the walls in that space. Costume Consultant Michel Pratka does similar things with her simplicity in choosing nothing flashy or fancy; truly reflecting the notion of the hopeless in this play. Their outfits are appropriate for the time – and not too grimy but just used and worn enough to show the tough times the characters have suffered.

Photos from top to bottom: Photo 1: Front Row: Tony Colavito, Rodney Bonds, Mark Scharf, Michael Robinson Back Row: William Walker, Ian Bonds, Mike Papa, David Morey, John Hurley, Rick Stover, and Tim Evans. Photo by Ken Stanek.
The actors try valiantly to breathe life into this very convoluted and semi-political diatribe. The play itself and presents difficult challenges to captivating audiences attentions; not from lack of trying on the cast’s behalf. Many of the actors create brilliant characters – complete with accents and gestures unique to their background but most of these are drowned out in the large crowd scenes where many groups begin talking at once with no specific intention of having one set of dialogue heard over another. The nuances and clever craftiness of these characters are lost in the throng of the masses; perhaps the intent of both playwright and director, as scene after scene of confusion unfolds on the stage. There are moments when two characters will be talking, maybe Larry (Mark Scharf) and Parritt (David Shoemaker) and their conversation is drowned out by other characters talking; the focus split two, three, and four ways on stage creating a roaring cacophonous din. It is even said at one point in the show that the barflies have lost their desire to communicate with the outside world; a poignant statement in the sense that this play seems to have lost its desire to communicate effectively with the audience.
There are moments of tension that should build as indicated by the lines of the play that just don’t seem to land here between the characters. Larry (Mark Scharf) often faces explosive moments of conflict against Parritt (David Shoemaker) but both actors seem to play at the same level – regardless of how the words cry out for passion, emotion, rage, and other notions of expression. Scharf takes a more subtle approach when cursing Parritt, flatly whispering lines like “you can’t make me be your executioner! You can’t make me judge you.” And Parritt does the same, simply speaking lines like “Please, Larry you have to understand I didn’t mean for her to get caught,” when these lines might better be delivered with conflict, guilt, or sorrow pouring from his cries.
Harry (Rodney Bonds) is the only one that seems to express his rage and emotions fully, but he falls victim to playing his emotions at the vocal extreme of loud. All of his outbursts reach the same shouting level as his jovial voice in a crowd; making them feel lackluster and redundant. Bonds delivers harrowing one-line interruptions at the end of the play; his face haunted; a redeeming moment for this actor. Hickey (Tony Colavito) is a strong presence throughout the performance. He commits fully to his suave yet dangerous character; stirring up trouble and can be clearly heard regardless of when he speaks. Perhaps this is because his character has the most lines and continues to talk over everyone no matter what they are saying. But Colavito is cheated out of brilliant moment at the end where his character should have shined. By the end of the show Colavito’s character delivers an epic monologue nearing ten minutes in length; containing poignant heartfelt confessions of a man tortured by pipe dreams into madness. But the beauty and gravity of this monologue is drowned out by the length of time it finally took to get there and then by the length of the monologue itself. As Harry (Bonds) shouts periodically throughout this monologue “enough we don’t want to hear anymore!” the audience relates and agrees.
The play is long – extremely drawn out and slow-paced. But keep your eyes on the hookers. Pearl (Anne Shoemaker), Margie (Deirdre McAllister), and Cora (Whitney St. Ours) provide great vibrant characters among the throng of depression. They are tarts, not whores, or so you’ll hear them say over and over. But even with their repetitive lines and predictable outbursts, they deliver them with conviction and commitment making them engaging and exciting in this drab drag. Their interactions with Rocky (Frank Vince) the barkeeper non-pimp are priceless. He only slaps them around like a man would his wife when she deserves it, so he’s not a pimp. These four actors keep you going in moments where you might be tempted to nod off or zone out – so keep your eye on them!
Running Time: 3 hours and 30 minutes, plus one brief intermission.
The generous 3 star rating was given to honor the hard-working cast.
The Iceman Cometh plays through February 12, 2012, at The Fells Point Corner Theatre – 251 South Ann Street, Baltimore, MD. For tickets, call the box office at (410) 276-7837, or purchase them online













